Homemade
Whipped
Pies to make you smile!
Spread a little joy.
Cutie Pies & Co. mixes taste with intention. We know that desserts are more than sweets, they're an experience. There's comfort in homemade pies, joy in sweet toppings, and happiness in our light and fluffy filling. We serve hand whipped pies meant to make our customers smile.
We look forward to your visit, and hope that we get to bake you happy!
Hand Whipped
Made fresh daily from
premium ingredients
On the Menu
Delicious Toppings
Comfort food you can enjoy
any time of day
Sweet Combos
Guaranteed to satisfy every
sweet craving
Behind the scenes
Meet your bakers!
Sister duo Laila and Lania are committed to their craft of providing the best homemade, hand-whipped pies in the Midwest.
test kitchen
Cutie Pies is constantly cooking up something new in our test kitchen,
so we can offer seasonal speciality pies alongside our bestsellers.
Desserts Doing Good
We love cooking for you! But we also want to bake others happy. Cutie Pies does partner with other local community organizations.
Get in touch with us!
Indianapolis, Indiana
on Facebook
Cutie Pie's
MENU
Original 🍦 Cutie - $5
Fruit Topped 🍰 Cutie's -$7
Specialty 🍪 Cutie's -$8
(ie...Oreo, Peanut Butter).
&
4/$20
Mix n' Match